GitHubMeanwhile, on GitHub...

Wrestling with Code

When my mentors first introduced me to the concept of "code smells," I found myself struggling to develop that instinctive sense they seemed to have. That's why I've created this comprehensive guide based on Robert C. Martin's "Clean Code" Chapter 17, breaking down these crucial concepts into digestible sections.

Introduction

Think of code smells like that slight odor in your refrigerator—they're subtle hints that something needs attention. They're not bugs per se, but rather indicators that your code might need some refinement. As developers, learning to identify these smells is crucial for maintaining healthy codebases.

Essential Categories of Code Smells

1. Comments 📝

Comments should clarify intent, not obscure it:

  1. Inappropriate Information

    • Smell: Including record-keeping or metadata in source code
    • Fix: Move this information to external documentation systems

  2. Obsolete Comments

    • Smell: Comments that no longer match the code
    • Fix: Delete outdated comments, ensure remaining ones stay current

  3. Redundant Comments

    • Smell: Comments that restate the obvious
    • Fix: Let clear code speak for itself

  4. Poorly Written Comments

    • Smell: Unclear or imprecise documentation
    • Fix: Write brief, focused comments that add value

  5. Commented-Out Code

    • Smell: Dead code left as comments
    • Fix: Delete it—version control exists for a reason

2. Functions 🔧

Functions should be clear, focused, and purposeful:

  1. Argument Management

    • Smell: Too many arguments (3+)
    • Fix: Aim for zero arguments, increase only when necessary

  2. Output Arguments

    • Smell: Using parameters for output
    • Fix: Prefer return values or modify object state

  3. Flag Arguments

    • Smell: Boolean parameters controlling behavior
    • Fix: Split into separate, focused functions

  4. Dead Functions

    • Smell: Unused methods
    • Fix: Remove them, add only when needed

  5. Function Purpose

    • Smell: Functions doing multiple things
    • Fix: Break into smaller, single-purpose functions

  6. Abstraction Levels

    • Smell: Mixed abstraction levels in one function
    • Fix: Keep function statements at one level below the function name

3. General Code Organization 🏗️

Overall structure and organization matters:

  1. Language Mixing

    • Smell: Multiple languages in one file
    • Fix: Separate languages into different files

  2. Boundary Behavior

    • Smell: Edge cases handled poorly
    • Fix: Test and handle all boundary conditions

  3. Code Duplication

    • Smell: Repeated code patterns
    • Fix: Use abstractions and polymorphism

  4. Abstraction Levels

    • Smell: Mixed high and low-level concepts
    • Fix: Separate into appropriate abstraction layers

  5. Dead Code

    • Smell: Unreachable or unused code
    • Fix: Delete it without mercy

  6. Vertical Separation

    • Smell: Variables declared far from usage
    • Fix: Declare close to where they're used

4. Object-Oriented Design 🎯

Proper OO principles improve maintainability:

  1. Base Class Dependencies

    • Smell: Base classes knowing about derivatives
    • Fix: Use proper inheritance hierarchies

  2. Feature Envy

    • Smell: Methods too interested in other classes' data
    • Fix: Move method to the class it's most interested in

  3. Selector Arguments

    • Smell: Arguments controlling method behavior
    • Fix: Create separate methods for different behaviors

  4. Inappropriate Static

    • Smell: Static methods that should be instance methods
    • Fix: Use static only when behavior will never vary

5. Names and Identifiers 📛

Clear naming is crucial for understanding:

  1. Descriptive Names

    • Smell: Unclear or ambiguous names
    • Fix: Choose names that reveal intention

  2. Abstraction Level Names

    • Smell: Names not matching abstraction level
    • Fix: Name according to the abstraction level

  3. Standard Nomenclature

    • Smell: Inconsistent naming patterns
    • Fix: Follow established conventions

  4. Unambiguous Names

    • Smell: Names that could mean multiple things
    • Fix: Be specific and clear

  5. Scope-Appropriate Names

    • Smell: Short names in wide scopes
    • Fix: Use longer names for wider scopes

6. Tests ✅

Tests are your safety net:

  1. Coverage Issues

    • Smell: Insufficient test coverage
    • Fix: Test all possible failure modes

  2. Boundary Testing

    • Smell: Untested edge cases
    • Fix: Explicitly test all boundaries

  3. Test Speed

    • Smell: Slow-running tests
    • Fix: Optimize test execution time

  4. Ignored Tests

    • Smell: Disabled or skipped tests
    • Fix: Either fix or remove ignored tests

Practical Implementation Tips

  1. Start Small

    • Focus on one category at a time
    • Build your "code smell" detection skills gradually
    • Use automated tools to help identify issues

  2. Regular Review

    • Schedule regular code review sessions
    • Use this checklist during reviews
    • Share findings with your team

  3. Continuous Improvement

    • Make small, incremental improvements
    • Document common issues and solutions
    • Build team awareness of code smells

The Bottom Line

Remember that developing a nose for code smells takes time and practice. Keep this guide handy as a reference, but don't feel overwhelmed—focus on addressing the most impactful issues first and gradually work your way through the rest.

  • Pick one category of smells to focus on
  • Set up automated tools to catch common issues
  • Practice identifying smells in code reviews
  • Share what you learn with your team

Code smells aren't just problems—they're opportunities to improve. By learning to identify and address them, you're not just fixing code; you're becoming a better developer.

Stay tuned for Appendix A: Concurrency II (this is a remix!).

Read More